The analysed aspect |
Assessment criteria |
Score (1-5) |
Structure |
C1 Adequacy with the titleC2 Coherence of the paper |
5 |
Research motivation |
C3 Clarity of presentation of the research problemC4 Argumentation of the research |
5 |
Theoretical substantiation |
C5 Relevance of cited sources and information presentedC6 Timeliness of the sourcesC7 Completeness of the sources |
4 |
Research methodology |
C8 Presentation of the time, participants, material researchC9 Description of the using of methods and toolsC10 Presentation of research design |
5 |
Research results |
C11 Presentation in the text (essential aspects, details, systematization, coherence) |
5 |
C12 Representing the results on the map (content, correctness of execution, thematic coverage of the subject, relevance) |
5 |
C13 Representing the results on charts (content, relevance, correctness of execution) |
5 |
C14 Presentation of the space in photographs (content, clarity, relevance) |
5 |
Discussions |
C15 Situation in space (spatial relationships, city-district relationship, relationship with environmental components, etc.) |
5 |
C16 Situation in time (evolution of the city and district) |
5 |
C17 Geographic characterization of the studied area |
5 |
C18 Urban development of the studied area |
5 |
C19 Characterization of each element (TRU) |
5 |
C20 Highlighting strengths and opportunitiesC21 Highlighting dysfunctions/ weaknesses/ threats |
4 |
C22 Presenting measures/solution, proposals in order to eliminate the problems/ dysfunctions/ weaknesses/ threats/dangers and to optimize the functionality of the district |
4 |
Conclusions |
C23 Synthesis, highlighting features and site specificity |
3 |
Writing the scientific paper |
C24 Respecting the structure of a scientific paper (title, introduction, theoretical foundation, method, results, discussions, conclusions, bibliography) |
2 |
C25 Respecting the requirements of a scientific paper (quoting sources, scientific language, systematization / organization, correctness and relevance of information, depth / coverage of details, composition of the bibliography) |
5 |
C26 Frame and aesthetics of the paper |
5 |
Total |
87 |
Mean |
4.57 |