Panel A—FP Measured by ROA |
|
WOM |
PWOM |
WWOM |
|
REM |
OLS |
REM |
OLS |
FEM |
OLS |
|
Model 1 |
Model 2 |
Model 1 |
Model 2 |
Model 1 |
Model 2 |
Intercept |
-2.152*(1.183) |
2.640(4.342) |
-1.826(1.115) |
-1.439(1.820) |
-1.879*(1.086) |
-1.532(1.382) |
GENDER |
-0.124(0.136) |
-5.533(4.692) |
-0.003(0.003) |
-0.023(0.082) |
0.084(0.095) |
0.557(2.600) |
BOARD |
0.142(0.147) |
0.187(0.159) |
0.117(0.153) |
0.092(0.163) |
0.169(0.153) |
0.128(0.163) |
LEV |
-3.606***(1.068) |
-4.005***(1.201) |
-3.731***(1.106) |
-3.987***(1.189) |
-3.397***(1.089) |
-3.617***(1.196) |
SIZE |
0.125***(0.048) |
-0.070(0.178) |
0.113**(0.045) |
0.104(0.074) |
0.106**(0.042) |
0.099*(0.054) |
GENDER*SIZE |
|
0.216(0.190) |
|
0.001(0.003) |
|
-0.024(0.100) |
N |
90 |
90 |
90 |
|
90 |
90 |
Adj. R2 |
12.33% |
9.06% |
12.70% |
13.88% |
8.72% |
11.30% |
F-Test |
3.65*** |
2.77** |
3.08*** |
2.71** |
3.60*** |
2.14* |
Haussman test |
4.69 |
- |
6.16 |
- |
22.68*** |
- |
Panel B—FP Measured by ROE |
|
WOM |
PWOM |
WWOM |
|
REM |
OLS |
FEM |
OLS |
FEM |
OLS |
|
Model 1 |
Model 2 |
Model 1 |
Model 2 |
Model 1 |
Model 2 |
Intercept |
-13.722(14.349) |
87.271(53.613) |
-14.006(12.354) |
-24.341(22.716) |
-16.006(11.982) |
-19.550(16.973) |
GENDER |
-0.235(1.643) |
-113.882*(57.938) |
0.073**(0.041) |
0.802(1.027) |
2.699**(1.053) |
51.635(31.930) |
BOARD |
-0.746(1.780) |
0.423***(1.966) |
-0.296(1.731) |
-1.176(2.028) |
-0.054(1.692) |
-0.2591.997 |
LEV |
-42.901***(12.935) |
-52.141***(14.830) |
-37.256***(12.409) |
-45.847***(14.836) |
-37.063***(12.016) |
-40.384***(14.691) |
SIZE |
1.164**(0.581) |
-2.970(2.202) |
1.047**(0.496) |
1.672*(0.918) |
1.130**(0.469) |
1.334**(0.660) |
GENDER*SIZE |
|
4.552*(2.348) |
|
-0.034(0.040) |
|
-1.996(1.231) |
N |
90 |
90 |
90 |
90 |
90 |
90 |
Adj. R2 |
10.23% |
14.96% |
4.79% |
12.86% |
6.55% |
13.06% |
F-Test |
5.83*** |
2.95* |
6.26*** |
2.48** |
7.26*** |
2.52** |
Haussman test |
7.01 |
- |
89.91*** |
- |
18.37*** |
- |
Panel C—FP Measured by ROIC |
|
WOM |
PWOM |
WWOM |
|
FEM |
OLS |
FEM |
OLS |
FEM |
OLS |
|
Model 1 |
Model 2 |
Model 1 |
Model 2 |
Model 1 |
Model 2 |
Intercept |
-4.494(8.127) |
50.723*(29.974) |
-5.557(7.405) |
-10.579(12.765) |
-7.303(7.339) |
-9.377(9.471) |
GENDER |
1.045(0.945) |
-61.229*(32.392) |
0.053**(0.024) |
0.417(0.577) |
1.379**(0.645) |
24.965(17.817) |
BOARD |
-1.336(1.030) |
-0.871(1.099) |
-0.793(1.038) |
-1.466(1.140) |
-0.834(1.036) |
-1.177(1.114) |
LEV |
-43.536***(7.411) |
-47.105***(8.291) |
-40.209***(7.438) |
-42.353***(8.337) |
-41.237***(7.360) |
-40.906***(8.198) |
SIZE |
0.689**(0.329) |
-1.550(1.231) |
0.663**(0.297) |
0.976*(0.516) |
0.765***(0.287) |
0.888**(0.368) |
GENDER*SIZE |
|
2.480**(1.313) |
|
-0.017(0.023) |
|
-0.957(0.687) |
N |
90 |
90 |
90 |
90 |
90 |
90 |
Adj. R2 |
27.43% |
27.47% |
24.13% |
24.88% |
26.08% |
26.09% |
F-Test |
3.71*** |
7.73*** |
4.31*** |
6.90*** |
4.27*** |
7.28*** |
Haussman test |
127.36*** |
- |
38.05*** |
- |
102.18*** |
- |
Panel D—FP Measured by EPS |
|
WOM |
PWOM |
WWOM |
|
REM |
OLS |
REM |
OLS |
REM |
OLS |
|
Model 1 |
Model 2 |
Model 1 |
Model 2 |
Model 1 |
Model 2 |
Intercept |
-2.220(1.449) |
6.515(4.779) |
-2.367**(1.348) |
-0.430(2.024) |
-2.520*(1.327) |
-1.836(1.523) |
GENDER |
0.075(0.163) |
-9.812*(5.164) |
0.002(0.004) |
-0.115(0.092) |
-0.019(0.108) |
-2.650(2.864) |
BOARD |
-0.625***(0.175) |
-0.560***(0.175) |
-0.606***(0.179) |
-0.572***(0.181) |
-0.632***(0.179) |
-0.637***(0.179) |
LEV |
-5.260***(1.287) |
-5.980***(1.322) |
-5.168***(1.317) |
-5.374***(1.322) |
-5.345***(1.307) |
-5.491***(1.318) |
SIZE |
0.182***(0.059) |
-0.178(0.196) |
0.186***(0.054) |
0.108(0.082) |
0.197***(0.052) |
0.171***(0.059) |
GENDER*SIZE |
|
0.401*(0.209) |
|
0.005(0.004) |
|
0.102(0.110) |
N |
90 |
90 |
90 |
90 |
90 |
90 |
Adj. R2 |
43.04% |
36.80% |
34.04% |
35.30% |
33.90% |
34.56% |
F-Test |
13.05*** |
9.78*** |
43.86*** |
9.17 |
11.09*** |
8.87*** |
Haussman test |
2.60 |
- |
4.68 |
- |
3.34 |
- |